Week 8 Class 3/3 — From Evidence to Value
NST Entrepreneurship · Founder Lab
Week 8 — Class 3/3

FROM EVIDENCE → VALUE
I'M NOT TEACHING YOU
ANOTHER FORMULA TODAY.
Today
WHAT DO YOU DO WHEN ALL OF THEM
APPEAR IN THE SAME CASE?
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
01
FROM EVIDENCE → VALUE
I'M NOT TEACHING YOU
ANOTHER FORMULA TODAY.
Today
WHAT DO YOU DO WHEN ALL OF THEM
APPEAR IN THE SAME CASE?
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
01
WHAT AM I TRYING TO PROVE?
CLAIM A
“This problem is painful.”
CLAIM B
“This customer will pay.”
CLAIM C
“This could become a scalable venture.”
WOULD YOU USE THE SAME EVIDENCE FOR ALL THREE?
NO. THE QUESTION DETERMINES WHAT MATTERS.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
02
CLAIM → EVIDENCE → GAP
CLAIM
Students desperately need this.
REQUIRED EVIDENCE
Repeated pain · workaround · sacrifice · behaviour
OBSERVED EVIDENCE
73% survey says “useful”
GAP
No behavioural evidence.
THE DATA MAY NOT BE BAD.
IT MAY BE ANSWERING THE WRONG QUESTION.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
03
WHICH EVIDENCE HELPS PROVE:
“THE PROBLEM IS REAL AND PAINFUL”?
Evidence sort
01:00
B + C direct · E economic seriousness · A/D other questions · F may be irrelevant
STRENGTH ≠ RELEVANCE.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
04
VALUE PROPOSITION ≠ FEATURE LIST
“AI-powered dashboard with alerts, recommendations and analytics.”
FOR [CUSTOMER]
WHO STRUGGLES WITH [JOB / PAIN]
WE HELP THEM ACHIEVE [OUTCOME]
UNLIKE [CURRENT ALTERNATIVE]
BECAUSE [EVIDENCE-BACKED ADVANTAGE]
CUSTOMERS BUY A CHANGE IN THEIR WORLD.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
05
JOB → PAIN → VALUE
CUSTOMER JOB
Know whether a campus lab has available PCs.
PAIN
Walk across campus and discover it is full.
SOLUTION
Live lab occupancy.
WHAT IS THE VALUE?
NOT “LIVE OCCUPANCY.” THAT IS THE SOLUTION.
REDUCED UNCERTAINTY + AVOIDED WASTED TIME.
SOLUTION ≠ VALUE.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
06
VALUE PROPOSITION CANVAS
CUSTOMER PROFILE
JOBS
What are they trying to accomplish?
PAINS
What makes it difficult, costly or risky?
GAINS
What outcome matters?
VALUE MAP
PRODUCTS / SERVICES
What do we provide?
PAIN RELIEVERS
What pain specifically changes?
GAIN CREATORS
What useful outcome improves?
DO NOT FILL THIS FROM YOUR IMAGINATION.
EVERY IMPORTANT BOX NEEDS EVIDENCE.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
07
VPC IS A MATCHING PROBLEM
CUSTOMER PAIN
“I don't know whether the lab has available PCs until I walk there.”
AI STUDY PLANNER
MATCH?
NO.
LIVE LAB OCCUPANCY
MATCH?
MUCH STRONGER.
TECHNICALLY IMPRESSIVE ≠ CUSTOMER VALUABLE.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
08
DELETE 4.
“I lose 20 minutes finding available parking.”
VPC murder
01:30
FOR EACH SURVIVOR: WHAT EVIDENCE JUSTIFIES KEEPING IT?
BUILD LESS. MATCH BETTER.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
09
WHAT IF THE DATA DISAGREES?
SURVEY
82%
“I'd definitely use this.”
INTERVIEWS
12 / 15
describe the pain
PILOT
10
sign up
WEEK 4
2
remain active
SO… IS THE PROBLEM REAL OR NOT?
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
10
CONTRADICTION ≠ BAD DATA
SURVEY
Perceived desirability
INTERVIEW
Problem recognition
SIGNUP
Initial intent
USAGE
Delivered value
RETENTION
Repeated value
PAYMENT
Economic value
82% → 2 RETAINED MAY NOT BE A CONTRADICTION.
IT MAY SHOW YOU WHERE THE THESIS BREAKS.
DIFFERENT EVIDENCE TESTS DIFFERENT HYPOTHESES.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
11
FIND THE BROKEN LINK
PROBLEM
STRONGCUSTOMER
STRONGVALUE
?ADOPTION
STRONGRETENTION
WEAKECONOMICS
?WHERE DO YOU INVESTIGATE?
DON'T RE-PROVE THE PART THAT ALREADY WORKS.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
12
FOUNDER STORY vs. DATA
“CUSTOMERS LOVE US.”
Rewrite the claim
00:30
SIGNUPS
80
ACTIVATED
48
USED TWICE
31
ACTIVE DAY 30
7
PAID
0
“Initial acquisition and activation show interest, but sustained usage and willingness to pay remain unproven.”
PRECISION OF LANGUAGE = PRECISION OF THINKING.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
13
EVERY BEAUTIFUL CONCLUSION
HAS A CHAIN UNDER IT.
“THIS CAN BECOME A ₹100CR COMPANY.”
ATTACK THE CHAIN. NOT THE HEADLINE.
EVERY ARROW CONTAINS AN ASSUMPTION.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
14
THE WEAKEST LINK
Problem exists
STRONG
ICP correct
STRONG
Customer will try
MEDIUM
Customer will pay
WEAK
Customer repeats
UNKNOWN
Channel scales
UNKNOWN
₹10,000
7 DAYS
ONE EXPERIMENT
WHAT DO YOU TEST?
DON'T SPEND EXPERIMENTS RE-PROVING WHAT YOU ALREADY KNOW.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
15
WHICH UNKNOWN DESERVES
THE NEXT EXPERIMENT?
1. HOW UNCERTAIN IS IT?
2. IF I'M WRONG, HOW MUCH DOES THE DECISION CHANGE?
LOW UNCERTAINTY
LOW IMPACT
IGNORE
LOW UNCERTAINTY
HIGH IMPACT
MONITOR
HIGH UNCERTAINTY
LOW IMPACT
LATER
HIGH UNCERTAINTY
HIGH IMPACT
TEST NOW
TEST WHAT CAN CHANGE THE DECISION.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
16
CAN YOU COMPRESS THE ENTIRE STARTUP INTO SIX LINES?
The Founder Memo
NO STORYTELLING FLUFF. SIX LINES. SIX DECISIONS.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
17
3-MINUTE FOUNDER MEMO
21 complain about late-night food
12 already order outside campus
8 agree to trial
2 reorder
Average order = ₹220
Delivery economics unknown
STRONGEST EVIDENCE
BIGGEST UNKNOWN
NEXT 30-DAY BET
KILL / CHANGE CONDITION
NOT “GET MORE CUSTOMERS.” BE SPECIFIC.
Write only four lines
03:00
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
18
READ IT LIKE AN INVESTOR.
ONLY THEN
→USE THE RELEVANT FRAMEWORK / CALCULATION.
NUMBERS ARE TOOLS. NOT THE STARTING POINT.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
19
THE QUESTION IS YOUR FILTER.
CAC?
Look for
Acquisition spend
Relevant costs
Customers acquired
Channel · Period
SOM?
Look for
Target population
Qualification
Reachability
Serviceability · Capture
WTP?
Look for
Payment · Deposit
Price test
Existing spend
Economic sacrifice
VALUE PROPOSITION?
Look for
Jobs · Pains
Alternatives
Sacrifices
Outcomes · Behaviour
GO / REFINE / PIVOT / STOP?
Look for
Evidence
Contradictions
Economics · Unknowns
Experiment results
DON'T READ EVERY ROW WITH EQUAL ATTENTION.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
20
DO CUSTOMERS RECEIVE ENOUGH REPEATED VALUE TO JUSTIFY CONTINUING?
CIRCLE ONLY THE ROWS YOU NEED.
Final battle
01:00
WHY DID YOU IGNORE TAM?
BECAUSE TAM DOES NOT ANSWER THIS QUESTION.
THE QUESTION IS YOUR FILTER.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
21
NOW YOU'RE THE INVESTMENT COMMITTEE.
FRAMEWORKS CALCULATE. EVIDENCE UPDATES. CONTRADICTIONS DIAGNOSE.
EXPERIMENTS REDUCE UNCERTAINTY. FOUNDERS DECIDE.
50 MINUTES. ONE COMPANY. TOO MUCH INFORMATION. NO PERFECT ANSWER.
READ. ATTACK. DECIDE. DEFEND.
NST FOUNDER LAB · WEEK 8 · CLASS 3/3
22
